Character and Range
Warm, bright and pastoral at the bottom; dark and bleak at the top; the middle is neither. Darkness is a mood and not a weight: a quiet record can be as dark as a heavy one and a heavy record can be bright, so answer this without looking at Intensity. Around 25 for Yes and Camel, 80 for Hérésie, Red and Opeth - and Tilt sits at 98 and Passion and Warfare at 30 with much the same force behind each.
Every prog release in the scored set with a value on this scale, at what the community has it at, split at the middle and ordered outwards from the top. Non-prog records that mark the bottom of a scale are left out; the chart shows them if you ask it to.
Close to the Edge 1972 | ||
Moonmadness 1976 | ||
Hot Rats 1969 | ||
Leftoverture 1976 | ||
Space Shanty 1972 | ||
To Be Kind 2014 | ||
First Utterance 1971 | ||
Om 2006 | ||
Every value here is what the membership has the record at: the same trust-weighted blend of every member's placement that the record's own page shows, on the twenty-seven scales and the three criteria alike. Nothing here reads one member's rows. Which records are on the map is a judgement in two parts: SiteCurator and Mike mark a record at full relevance, and the membership must hold it at 60 or more on one of the three criteria, so getting a record onto this page is those two accounts' call, and keeping it here is everyone's. The non-prog records are the exception: they mark the bottom of a scale, so the second test would rule them out.
Today that blend is thin. Of the 270 records here, 34 have more than one member behind them, and the rest stand on a single assessment. Most came from one automated pass by a machine account, which makes the rows comparable but is also the whole of their authority. Nobody has checked that pass.
The three criteria marked beside each release are shaky too: around half of their values were never typed by anybody, since assigning a genre that implies a criterion writes it onto your rows. So a tick is not reliably anyone's opinion.
Only members can fix both. Open a record you know well (the scored set is a good start) and score it under Coordinates in its editor. You need not answer all twenty-seven scales; the ones you are sure of beat a complete guess. Answer the three criteria directly rather than leaving a genre to do it. Your values move these pages too, so a second and third assessor are all it takes for a scale to become the site's reading.