Topic: Porcupine Tree x2

Posted
bartyMJ
joined
posted

Two things, both probably a bit pedantic.

First one is easy, album title needs a 'The..' : https://awesomeprog.com/releases/14147

Second one, Voyage 34 - https://awesomeprog.com/releases/14134 Lots of info taken from different versions of this which is a bit confusing. The Spotify and Bandcamp links are to the compilation of the 'Complete Trip' four phases, released in 2000 but remastered several times and with the 2004 cover art. The track lengths listed on the tracklist of the release page are the 2004 remaster (Phase 4 slightly longer). Not sure where the PA links etc are picking up from. The release itself is listed as an album (incorrect) and as released in 1992 (this was the release date of the original 30 minute Voyage 34 before it was split in two and before the Phase 3 and 4 remixes. Would imagine the majority of reviews/blurbs/ratings would be for the complete 4 phase trip so would suggest updating the release page to be a compilation released in 2000 maybe?

Mike
joined
posted

Fixed TSMS title and added the remaining (bonus) tracks.

Regarding Voyage 34, that one is not easy. Changed it to EP and made tracks 3 and 4 a bonus. At AwesomeProg we focus on LPs and EPs, let's ignore the compilations. Regarding the cover art, I'm inclined to go with the 2004 version since it's the one that most fans know.

bartyMJ
joined
posted

The philosophical question, when does an EP/LP become a compilation ;-)

To be fair I'd be classing Voyage 34 as a four track EP anyway, and particularly as the full four tracks is what most people would be able to buy/stream and review, so fully behind your solution. As you say, not an easy one given the way it was all released!

You need to sign in to post replies.